That's a tough one to decide, since both shirts look incredible. I think I'll go with Aguspineiro on this one - the Tartan pattern not only strikes as pretty, but it's also very fitting to the club. Kudos to Silky Smooth as well - his gradient pattern looks great, and I really liked how he 'blended' the Macron logo and the collar, a small detail that made a difference to the kit.

These are 2 very good designs but Silky Smooth just edges it for me.