It is a bit difficult to pic one rater then the other here, both have the same problem with the logos on their kits, they are a bit to small for my liking. I feel Tappei should have used a gold shade in his kit in stead of yellow, I think that would have maid all the difference, this yellow color is somehow not working with the blue. The Ecuador kit is fine and I personally have always found it difficult to design a yellow kits but I think Buttplug has found a good shade of yellow here that matches well with the vertical stripes in his kit, it is a simple design that works well so he gets my vote here.
[b]Tappei[/b]. While I agree that templates aren't that great for competition entries, I think the sash and the glowing details are sufficient. Ecuador kit looks good, but I'm not a huge fan of these kits featuring 2-or-3-colour horizontal stripes (Maybe because I watch Brazilian football a lot and can't stand this design anymore. São Paulo and Bahia home kits, as well as Flamengo, Fluminense, Gremio, Vitoria eventual away kits. And I'm only couting teams in the Serie A. lol).