comments would be appreciated

Not a big fan of any of them, that doesn't mean I like their current one, just the shape is exactly the same dull one and the roof of the cottage looks just odd , the galley is also completely necessary and unrelated to anything to do with the club.

The cross, swords and text are the best bit about it, just need displaying in a different way.

the galley is on the fulham and hammersmith coat of arms and it was also on fulham's badge they used in the 80s.

4 is the best imo

I checked out the reason behind the galley on the coat of arms before I posted. It was because a band of pirates set up camp there around 900AD and nothing more than that. If that's not insignificant to the football team or even the area I don't know what is.

I didn't actually say last time but if was picking one it'-) be 3

Very interesting concepts! I agree with you about the current badge, this definitely makes it more interesting.
Id stick with N.2 :D:

If choosing by the impact of the crest, I would choose 4, as that would look hte most imposing on the shirt, so I would go for that one

2

1